Q1 2015 Patent Dispute Report

Figure 1:  440 PTAB petitions were filed in Q1 2015, nearly double the petitions filed in Q1 2014.

PTAB Petitions FiledNPENon-NPE2012Q32012Q42013Q12013Q22013Q32013Q42014Q12014Q22014Q32014Q42015Q10150300450600
QuarterNon-NPENPE
2012 Q3214
2012 Q44244
2013 Q16234
2013 Q29364
2013 Q312995
2013 Q4157158
2014 Q1102129
2014 Q2188309
2014 Q3231213
2014 Q4228275
2015 Q1244196

Figure 2:  Q1 2015 had 13% more District Court cases initiated than last year and 29% more than last quarter.

Comparison of Q1 2015 Patent LitigationNPENon-NPEQ1 2014Q4 2014Q1 2015040080012001600
MonthNon-NPENPE
Q1 2014479794
Q4 2014484632
Q1 2015547896

Figure 3: High-Tech had the majority of District Court and PTAB initiated disputes.

Patent Disputes in Q1 2015PTABLitigationHigh-TechMedicalOther040080012001600
MonthLitigationPTAB
High-Tech948267
Medical182103
Other31370

Figure 4: In Q1 2015, PTAB petitions reached 23% of initiated litigation.

Litigation and PTAB Filings by QuarterPTABLitigationQ1 2014Q4 2014Q1 2015040080012001600
QuarterPTABLitigation
Q1 20142311,273
Q4 20145031,116
Q1 20154401,443

Figure 5: NPE litigation made up 62% of Q1 2015 initiated District Court cases, compared to 62% in Q1 2014 and 57% in Q4 2014.

NPE Activity Q1 2015 LitigationNPENon-NPE37.9%62.1%
LitigationQuantity
NPE896
Non-NPE547

Figure 6: NPE litigation made up 84% of Q1 2015 High-Tech cases, compared to 70% in Q1 2014 and 63% in Q4 2014.

NPE Activity Q1 2015 High-Tech LitigationNPENon-NPE15.9%84.1%
High-Tech LitigationQuantity
NPE797
Non-NPE151

Figure 7:  In Q1 2015, the majority of High-Tech PTAB Petitions were filed against NPEs.

NPE Activity Q1 2015 High-Tech PTABNPENon-NPE46.4%53.6%
High Tech PTABQuantity
NPE143
Non-NPE124

Figure 8:  In Q1 2015, the five largest filers in District Court cases filed 203 cases, making up 14% of cases filed.

Largest Filers in Q1 2015 LitigationFilingsQommerceSystems, LLCAvioniqs, LLCOlivistar LLCData CarriersLLCWetro LanLLC2030405060
QuarterFilings
Qommerce Systems, LLC28
Avioniqs, LLC30
Olivistar LLC41
Data Carriers LLC49
Wetro Lan LLC55